If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
goldtech wrote:
Hi, I been making some expensive mistakes in dSLR purchases and want to ask here so I can hopefully avoid hair pulling in the future. What dSLRs have interchangeable focusing screens? And have a screens w/ split-image and micro/multi-prism? I am asking about true user interchangeability and a choice of screens from the manufacturer. Fx Canon models. Perhaps Sony a900? But I don't believe it's significantly harder to replace a screen on other maker's dslrs with aftermarket "Katz eye" screens. IMO split image is close to a total waste of time, as in most photography (apart from macro copy work perhaps) the desired focus point is never in the centre of the screen, and with shallow DOF where focus is critical, "focus and compose" technique is vastly inferior in practice than being able to put an (AF) focus point right where you want it. Microprism is useless with slow lenses, and it's usually also confined to center of the frame around the split image circle. YMMV. What dSLRs have auto focusing tweaking that the user can do via a menu? Some don't have this and required sending back to the service center - not good. I need user tweaking if it's ever necessary... Thanks, I'm missing these options on my current dSLR and I require them. Nikon D300/700/3/3x Canon 5dII, 50d and up. Sony a900. Some pentax / samsung models? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
Me wrote:
goldtech wrote: What dSLRs have interchangeable focusing screens? But I don't believe it's significantly harder to replace a screen on other maker's dslrs with aftermarket "Katz eye" screens. It depends on what you call "interchangeable" and "harder". There are some DSLRs in which you just move a little clip, pull out the old screen, drop in the new one, and push the clip back, and just about anybody could do that at home. (Most Canons, I think.) There are other models for which it's rather more difficult and not recommended for anybody who isn't an experienced technician. (Most Olympuses, for example..) But they're all "replaceable" in the sense that the screen isn't an integral part of the chassis or anything. I got an aftermarket focusing screen for my first DSLR, because I missed the old split prism. But eventually I came to realize it didn't matter that much, and when I got my second DSLR, I didn't bother with it and haven't missed it. I'd wait and think carefully about whether you really need an aftermarket screen before going ahead and doing it. Some people may really need it; I didn't. -- Oh to have a lodge in some vast wilderness. Where rumors of oppression and deceit, of unsuccessful and successful wars may never reach me anymore. -- William Cowper, 1731 - 1800 |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
On Thu, 30 Apr 2009 15:07:25 +0000 (UTC), Jeremiah DeWitt Weiner
wrote: : Me wrote: : goldtech wrote: : What dSLRs have interchangeable focusing screens? : : But I don't believe it's significantly harder to replace a screen on : other maker's dslrs with aftermarket "Katz eye" screens. : : It depends on what you call "interchangeable" and "harder". There : are some DSLRs in which you just move a little clip, pull out the old : screen, drop in the new one, and push the clip back, and just about : anybody could do that at home. (Most Canons, I think.) There are other : models for which it's rather more difficult and not recommended for : anybody who isn't an experienced technician. (Most Olympuses, for : example..) But they're all "replaceable" in the sense that the screen : isn't an integral part of the chassis or anything. : : I got an aftermarket focusing screen for my first DSLR, because I : missed the old split prism. But eventually I came to realize it didn't : matter that much, and when I got my second DSLR, I didn't bother with : it and haven't missed it. I'd wait and think carefully about whether : you really need an aftermarket screen before going ahead and doing it. : Some people may really need it; I didn't. In my experience, the biggest advantage of a replacement screen is grid lines to help with getting the horizontals and verticals right. Bob |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
Robert Coe wrote:
In my experience, the biggest advantage of a replacement screen is grid lines to help with getting the horizontals and verticals right. The Nikon D700 has grid lines that can be turned on and off. You don't need to buy a replacement screen. On the other hand, the grid lines also work when an aftermarket replacement screen is fitted, such as the Katz Eye. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
Bruce wrote:
Robert Coe wrote: In my experience, the biggest advantage of a replacement screen is grid lines to help with getting the horizontals and verticals right. The Nikon D700 has grid lines that can be turned on and off. You don't need to buy a replacement screen. On the other hand, the grid lines also work when an aftermarket replacement screen is fitted, such as the Katz Eye. Viewfinder gridlines are standard in most (all?) Nikon dslrs. AFAIK Nikon don't offer non-standard screens for any of their dslrs. I think that they're on the right track. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
Me wrote:
Bruce wrote: Robert Coe wrote: In my experience, the biggest advantage of a replacement screen is grid lines to help with getting the horizontals and verticals right. The Nikon D700 has grid lines that can be turned on and off. You don't need to buy a replacement screen. On the other hand, the grid lines also work when an aftermarket replacement screen is fitted, such as the Katz Eye. Viewfinder gridlines are standard in most (all?) Nikon dslrs. AFAIK Nikon don't offer non-standard screens for any of their dslrs. I think that they're on the right track. I got a Katz Eye for my D200 because I use a lot of old manual lenses. I decided that I don't really need it for the D700 because it's a bigger viewfinder and sometimes an annoying obstruction on the D200, though often useful. It's definitely not the sort of thing you would change in the field, it requires tweezers & a clean environment to prevent dust getting sandwiched in there. I would be curious to try something like Alan mentioned for his Sony, 'Acute Matte' but nobody seems to make such a thing for Nikons. The D200 has optional grid lines too, maybe not the D70 before that? I still am pretty bad about keeping the horizon straight :-( -- Paul Furman www.edgehill.net www.baynatives.com all google groups messages filtered due to spam |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
In article , Paul Furman
wrote: The D200 has optional grid lines too, maybe not the D70 before that? I still am pretty bad about keeping the horizon straight :-( d70 had grid lines |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
Paul Furman wrote:
I got a Katz Eye for my D200 because I use a lot of old manual lenses. I decided that I don't really need it for the D700 because it's a bigger viewfinder and sometimes an annoying obstruction on the D200, though often useful. The Katz Eye screen for the D700 is different from the Katz Eye screens for all other Nikon DSLRs. It is far less obtrusive - just a small central split image rangefinder without the surrounding microprism that the Katz Eye screens for every other Nikon DSLR share. See the comparison he http://www.katzeyeoptics.com/cat--Ni...cat_nikon.html It's definitely not the sort of thing you would change in the field, it requires tweezers & a clean environment to prevent dust getting sandwiched in there. Agreed - clinically clean conditions are required, and it should be fitted once only and left in place. I would be curious to try something like Alan mentioned for his Sony, 'Acute Matte' but nobody seems to make such a thing for Nikons. The Katz Eye screen is described as a "Laser Matte" and I find it excellent for focusing, and also for estimating depth of field at apertures of f/4 and smaller. The DOF at larger apertures doesn't really show, but that's true of just about any SLR focusing screen. There isn't yet a version with Optibrite treatment but one is stated to be under development. The D200 has optional grid lines too, maybe not the D70 before that? I'm not sure how many Nikon DSLRs have the switchable grid lines. The D3 definitely doesn't. I don't think the D3X has them either (although I would welcome a correction if it does). The first Nikon SLR to be fitted with them was the N80/F80. I still am pretty bad about keeping the horizon straight :-( AOL Me too. /AOL |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
In article , Bruce
wrote: The D200 has optional grid lines too, maybe not the D70 before that? I'm not sure how many Nikon DSLRs have the switchable grid lines. The D3 definitely doesn't. it does in live view, and it also has an artificial horizon. http://a.img-dpreview.com/reviews/Ni.../TV20070921145 01701.jpg |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Interchangeable focusing screens - which dSLRs ?
Bruce wrote:
I'm not sure how many Nikon DSLRs have the switchable grid lines. The D3 definitely doesn't. I don't think the D3X has them either (although I would welcome a correction if it does). The first Nikon SLR to be fitted with them was the N80/F80. According to specs, the D3 and D3x do have on-demand grid lines. I still am pretty bad about keeping the horizon straight :-( AOL Me too. /AOL Me too. The on-demand grid-lines aren't a cure-all. At wide-angle, they can be a nuisance, as they draw my attention to lines in the composition which aren't perfectly horizontal or vertical, and don't /need/ to be. I have the grid line toggle set in "my menu" so I can get to it easily in the field. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Digital SLR Focusing Screens | Matt Clara | Digital SLR Cameras | 13 | August 31st 05 12:31 AM |
cleaning Nikon focusing screens | RK | 35mm Photo Equipment | 5 | December 26th 04 03:38 AM |
FS focusing screens for Canon F1 & FN | 35mm Equipment for Sale | 0 | October 16th 04 11:17 PM | |
FS: Nikon B2 & E2 Focusing Screens - for FA, FM2, FE2. | Mac Breck | 35mm Equipment for Sale | 1 | June 7th 04 08:55 PM |
Hasselblad Focusing screens | DScheffold | Medium Format Photography Equipment | 2 | March 13th 04 10:43 AM |