If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
nikon 55mm f/1.2 over various 50mm f/1.4
I'm playing with an AI'd 55m f/1.2 on a D70 at the moment trying to work out whether to add it to my collection of an AIS 50mm f/1.4 and an AF 50mm f/1.4 (first version). At this point, I'd consider it potentially useful as a portrait-lens if it had a nice OOF rendition and softness that didn't get in the way too much. I've got the lens on loan at the moment and I'm trying to come up with some ways of pushing it to various limits to see what it can do, obviously a lens like that is going to have flare issues, but is there anything a little more subtle I could try? B |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"Bruce Murphy" wrote:
I'm playing with an AI'd 55m f/1.2 on a D70 at the moment trying to work out whether to add it to my collection of an AIS 50mm f/1.4 and an AF 50mm f/1.4 (first version). At this point, I'd consider it potentially useful as a portrait- lens if it had a nice OOF rendition and softness that didn't get in the way too much. I've got the lens on loan at the moment and I'm trying to come up with some ways of pushing it to various limits to see what it can do, obviously a lens like that is going to have flare issues, but is there anything a little more subtle I could try? Hi Bruce, I've owned a 55mm f/1.2 pre-AI Nikkor lens since purchasing it new with my first Nikon F2 in the early 70s. It was chosen because at that time I was working night shifts at Disneyland while attending college and I wanted to record the dim, behind-the-scenes times I spent with my friends. (I also own a 50mm f/1.8 AIS that is for general use where quality is more important than speed.) If you're interested, the following two SI submissions by me (one B&W and one color) were both made using this original 55mm lens wide-open at f/1.2. They are examples of "pushing it to various limits" and may be of some use to you in your decision: (Friday Night) http://www.pbase.com/shootin/image/30868043 One interesting thing to notice in the Friday Night photo is the blob of light on the extreme left edge of the picture, sitting just above the white fence. This was actually a point-source exposed halogen bulb illuminating the drive-thru ticket booth. Even though there is a 12% crop from the true left edge of the frame (meaning the bulb was not imaged at the extreme frame edge) this light source exhibits severe coma. You can also see the general overall softness of the subject elements as they were recorded during the wide-open, one-second, tripod-mounted (w/MLU engaged) exposure. (Heat) http://www.pbase.com/shootin/image/33170474 The Heat photo was a hand held 1/30 sec wide-open exposure (elbows braced on knees while sitting). The interesting thing here is the extremely shallow depth-of-field produced by this lens at such a close working distance. This is quite apparent along the length of the foreground log and is always a big challenge in dim light. One final thought is that in my experience this lens (all lenses, but especially so with this one) must be used with its respective lens hoods attached. As you can see, the front element is huge and *very* exposed to stray light. I have the very deep HS-3 metal screw-on shade and never fail to attach it. You would do well to obtain the same, or a similar, hood, if you can. Hope this helps, Ken |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"Ken Nadvornick" writes:
I've owned a 55mm f/1.2 pre-AI Nikkor lens since purchasing it new with my first Nikon F2 in the early 70s. It was chosen because at that time I was working night shifts at Disneyland while attending college and I wanted to record the dim, behind-the-scenes times I spent with my friends. (I also own a 50mm f/1.8 AIS that is for general use where quality is more important than speed.) If you're interested, the following two SI submissions by me (one B&W and one color) were both made using this original 55mm lens wide-open at f/1.2. They are examples of "pushing it to various limits" and may be of some use to you in your decision: Thanks for the pointers to images and to the comments. I'll probably try a couple of other tests to see how it might bite me in shots I do care about. One final thought is that in my experience this lens (all lenses, but especially so with this one) must be used with its respective lens hoods attached. As you can see, the front element is huge and *very* exposed to stray light. I have the very deep HS-3 metal screw-on shade and never fail to attach it. You would do well to obtain the same, or a similar, hood, if you can. I don't have the precise lens hood available at the moment, but it'll have to go on the list of things to acquire if I do end up getting the lens. I wonder how commonly they turn up. B |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Bruce Murphy wrote in message ...
I'm playing with an AI'd 55m f/1.2 on a D70 at the moment trying to work out whether to add it to my collection of an AIS 50mm f/1.4 and an AF 50mm f/1.4 (first version). At this point, I'd consider it potentially useful as a portrait-lens if it had a nice OOF rendition and softness that didn't get in the way too much. I've got the lens on loan at the moment and I'm trying to come up with some ways of pushing it to various limits to see what it can do, obviously a lens like that is going to have flare issues, but is there anything a little more subtle I could try? B The *50*mm f/1.2 AI-S lens is generally regarded as a step-up above in image quality over the 55mm f/1.2. I would be more inclined to make an "upgrade" along those lines versus buying a 50mm f/1.4. If you get the 50mm f/1.2, make sure to get the AI-S version as it has a 9-bladed diaphragm versus a 7-blade for the AI version. I don't think that the out-of-focus blur is any better with the f/1.4 versus the f/1.2, so even on that level there really is no improvement. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Nikon Coolpix 5700 severe flash underexposure problem | All Things Mopar | Digital Photography | 21 | November 2nd 04 05:38 AM |
50mm Nikon E vs Nikkor | Mike - EMAIL IGNORED | 35mm Photo Equipment | 3 | October 4th 04 04:11 AM |
55mm Nikon Micro AIS | Matt Clara | 35mm Photo Equipment | 10 | July 4th 04 01:05 AM |
Nikon 50mm f4.0 vs. 50mm f2.8 | Shawn H | In The Darkroom | 35 | March 7th 04 03:01 AM |