If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which
I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? Or is it the case that if when tested thoroughly immediately after purchase, it's more likely that a cheap card will not work, but that if it *does* work OK, then it's no more likely to fail in service than a branded card? Comments please! Thanks David |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
Lobster wrote:
I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? Or is it the case that if when tested thoroughly immediately after purchase, it's more likely that a cheap card will not work, but that if it *does* work OK, then it's no more likely to fail in service than a branded card? Comments please! Thanks David Card prices are coming down. Chances are good those are the same cards that were expensive a few months ago. -- Joseph Meehan Dia 's Muire duit |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
"Joseph Meehan" wrote in message ... Lobster wrote: I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? Or is it the case that if when tested thoroughly immediately after purchase, it's more likely that a cheap card will not work, but that if it *does* work OK, then it's no more likely to fail in service than a branded card? Comments please! Thanks David Card prices are coming down. Chances are good those are the same cards that were expensive a few months ago. Especially if they are "smaller" cards. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
I got burned with cheap cards!
1. They are usually Real Slow at reading, writing, and erasing. Beware! 2. The plastic case is of poor quality and can break inside your camera! I had one separate near the contacts and catch on the contacts inside the camera. It was hard to remove and when I pulled it out it ruined the contacts inside the camera. Camera had to go to the factory for repair. BEWARE! I'll never buy an off-brand card again. NM "Lobster" wrote in message ... I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? Or is it the case that if when tested thoroughly immediately after purchase, it's more likely that a cheap card will not work, but that if it *does* work OK, then it's no more likely to fail in service than a branded card? Comments please! Thanks David |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
~~NoMad~~ wrote:
I got burned with cheap cards! 1. They are usually Real Slow at reading, writing, and erasing. Beware! 2. The plastic case is of poor quality and can break inside your camera! I had one separate near the contacts and catch on the contacts inside the camera. It was hard to remove and when I pulled it out it ruined the contacts inside the camera. Camera had to go to the factory for repair. BEWARE! I'll never buy an off-brand card again. NM "Lobster" wrote in message ... I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? Or is it the case that if when tested thoroughly immediately after purchase, it's more likely that a cheap card will not work, but that if it *does* work OK, then it's no more likely to fail in service than a branded card? Comments please! Thanks David This type of failure is no respecter of brand name or price. I had a pricey 1GB Corsair 133X SD Card and it came apart at the seams.It was hard to fish out of its slot just as you described.. I stuck it back together with a dot of Krazy Glue and is has worked fine ever since. Fast 1GBs now are so cheap that I'll probably just keep the Corsair for use on my computers as a Removable H.D. Bob Williams |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
Lobster wrote:
I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? Or is it the case that if when tested thoroughly immediately after purchase, it's more likely that a cheap card will not work, but that if it *does* work OK, then it's no more likely to fail in service than a branded card? Comments please! Thanks David Unless it has changed, there are only a few places that actually manufacture flash memory chips. All the companies marketing these cards buy their chips from these few places, and there is little difference between the cards of similar capacity and speed. The only significant difference between an expensive and cheap SD card is the capacity and speed. Unless you have a top of the line DSLR or Pro-sumer type of camera, you probably will get no great benefit from the faster cards, so don't bother spending a lot of money on a fast card, or one from a more expensive brand. And DON'T fall for buying a card from the camera manufacturer as they ALWAYS are overpriced. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
~~NoMad~~ wrote:
I got burned with cheap cards! 1. They are usually Real Slow at reading, writing, and erasing. Beware! 2. The plastic case is of poor quality and can break inside your camera! I had one separate near the contacts and catch on the contacts inside the camera. It was hard to remove and when I pulled it out it ruined the contacts inside the camera. Camera had to go to the factory for repair. BEWARE! I'll never buy an off-brand card again. NM what did you do to the card to cause the plastic to break? Leave it in the sun to bake, or force it into the camera? This is the first I have ever heard of such a thing happening to anyone. I can't credit it as being at all common, for any card. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
On Fri, 25 May 2007 19:14:00 GMT, Lobster
wrote the following to uk.comp.misc: I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? At work we've had expensive Kingston USB flash drives fail pretty quickly and cheap no brand ones be pretty indestructible. I think most flash chips are made by Samsung regardless of which company's name is on the outside casing. Also worth remembering that if it *does* fail, you can use the sale & supply of goods to consumers act to get a replacement on the grounds that it's faulty. mh. -- http://www.nukesoft.co.uk http://personal.nukesoft.co.uk From address is a blackhole. Reply-to address is valid. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
Marcus Houlden wrote:
On Fri, 25 May 2007 19:14:00 GMT, Lobster wrote the following to uk.comp.misc: I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? At work we've had expensive Kingston USB flash drives fail pretty quickly and cheap no brand ones be pretty indestructible. I think most flash chips are made by Samsung regardless of which company's name is on the outside casing. Also worth remembering that if it *does* fail, you can use the sale & supply of goods to consumers act to get a replacement on the grounds that it's faulty. Thanks for the replies. My query was brought about by seeing this promo - 6 GBP for a 1Gb SD card, which sounded a good deal: http://uk.aldi.com/sunday_special_buys/productnl_224.html However, just been on Amazon and found Kingston-branded cards on sale for a mere 1.83 GBP. Is that really right or am I missing something? I was expecting these to be about 10 GBP a go?. See: http://tinyurl.com/2yw3k8 (or http://www.amazon.co.uk/Kingston-Technology-1GB-Digital-SD/dp/B00070QI1I/ref=sr_1_7/026-5345353-7024418?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1180189086&sr=1-7 Thanks David |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Cheap SD cards... OK?
"Lobster" wrote in message ... Marcus Houlden wrote: On Fri, 25 May 2007 19:14:00 GMT, Lobster wrote the following to uk.comp.misc: I was thinking of buying a number of cheap SD cards for my camera, which I've seen on offer... is this a good idea or not? I appreciate that "you get what you pay for" but what I'm getting at is if you buy cheapo memory is it inherently less reliable than expensive branded stuff, ie, might it fail later? At work we've had expensive Kingston USB flash drives fail pretty quickly and cheap no brand ones be pretty indestructible. I think most flash chips are made by Samsung regardless of which company's name is on the outside casing. Also worth remembering that if it *does* fail, you can use the sale & supply of goods to consumers act to get a replacement on the grounds that it's faulty. Thanks for the replies. My query was brought about by seeing this promo - 6 GBP for a 1Gb SD card, which sounded a good deal: http://uk.aldi.com/sunday_special_buys/productnl_224.html However, just been on Amazon and found Kingston-branded cards on sale for a mere 1.83 GBP. Is that really right or am I missing something? I was expecting these to be about 10 GBP a go?. See: http://tinyurl.com/2yw3k8 (or http://www.amazon.co.uk/Kingston-Technology-1GB-Digital-SD/dp/B00070QI1I/ref=sr_1_7/026-5345353-7024418?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1180189086&sr=1-7 Thanks David But its sold from Amazon not by Amazon so postage will be at £4,99 plus per item cost plus 1.83 I would try the Aldi If it fails you can just pop back in the store for replacement or refund |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Memory cards are cheap now | Mike Henley | Digital Photography | 8 | March 13th 06 02:19 AM |
FA: Digital, 3D, SubMini, 35mm Accs. Cheap*Cheap*Cheap | Bob R. | 35mm Equipment for Sale | 0 | June 11th 05 08:59 PM |
FA: Digital, 3D, SubMini, 35mm Accs. Cheap*Cheap*Cheap | Bob R. | Digital Photo Equipment For Sale | 0 | June 11th 05 08:59 PM |
Cheap SD 256 cards | [email protected] | Digital Photography | 1 | September 21st 04 12:54 PM |
Cheap source for Compact Flash cards? | nitzsche | Digital Photography | 12 | August 5th 04 12:49 PM |