If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Dpreview's reviews "Highly Recommended" is highly questionable
RichA wrote:
Both cameras got "highly recommended." Evidently, it's a highly flexible attribution. E-P1 versus D300 Olympus E-P1: Conclusion - Pros (14) Excellent resolution, tons of detail in the shots Appealing, bright and punchy out of camera results and well optimized JPEGs Very clever collapsible kit lens that's small, but offers decent quality Unique retro design puts SLR quality into a compact body Good high ISO performance up to ISO 3200 and lots of control over noise reduction Superb build quality Decent handling Dual control dials - unusual design that works well Lots of external control, easy access to photographic functions Comprehensive feature set and impressive level of customization Reliable metering and white balance (in natural light) Lots of stuff to play with; art filters, aspect ratios, multi-exposure and level gauge In body image stabilization Easy to use, high quality video mode Conclusion - Cons (10) Slow focus requires a more considered approach to shooting Some highlight clipping (and poor dynamic range at ISO 100) Low resolution screen that's hard to see in bright light No viewfinder No built-in flash (and the optional flash is expensive and pretty basic) Complicated menu system not that easy to navigate Preview image brightness doesn't always match the captured image brightness Poor focus, slow lens and jerky live view image make shooting in very low light frustrating, to say the least No AF illuminator The most interesting Art Filters slow down operation (and make the movie mode virtually useless) Nikon D300: Conclusion - Pros (30) * Very good resolution and detail without looking over-processed, even up to ISO 1600 * Better balanced noise reduction than most; more chroma NR, less luminance NR * High ISO 3200 perfectly usable (if slightly softer due to NR), ISO 6400 usable for small output * Highly configurable Auto ISO function (can set maximum ISO and minimum shutter speed) * Conservative approach to image processing (slightly lower sharpening) helps to avoid 'digital' artifacts * Excellent dynamic range from ISO 200 - 800 (good highlight 'reach'), typical at ISO 1600 * Seldom mentioned built-in chromatic aberration reduction is very effective (JPEG, RAWs through NX) * Compact, solid body design with environmental sealing * Quality glass pentaprism viewfinder (bright, large view) with electronic grid lines * Professional in-use performance (instant power-up, short shutter lag and short viewfinder black-out) * Improved auto-focus module (Multi-CAM3500DX) delivers fast and accurate AF lock even in low light * Auto-focus fine-tuning by body or per lens * Nikon's excellent 1005 pixel RGB metering sensor * Numerous 'hidden' designed-in features; AF tracking by color, scene recognition system * High speed continuous shooting (6 fps) can be boosted to 8 fps with grip & battery * 150,000 exposure shutter life * Now Nikon standard range of image parameter presets, addition of brightness adjustment * Superb large, high resolution LCD (delivers full-color VGA; 640xRGB x 480) * Live view with up to 1:1 pixel view, contrast detect AF as well as passive (mirror flip) AF * HDMI video output (up to 1080i) * Compact Flash UDMA support, very fast throughput overall * Menu system is a pleasure to use, attractive, logical and built- in help * Easy to use playback with very logical delete system (press delete button twice) * Highly configurable via custom functions (6 configurable hard buttons / dials) * Sophisticated interval timer feature * Unique in-camera features: Overlay, Multiple exposures * GPS data recording feature (requires optional cable, NMEA compatible) * Built-in AF assist lamp (white light) * Probably the best battery information display in the business (% charge, shots, aging) * Optional wireless WiFi transmitter (802.11 b/g) Conclusion - Cons (3) * No timed mirror lock-up function (could be automatic with self- timer) * Non-articulating LCD (increases the usefulness of Live View considerably) * Average automatic white balance performance, still very poor under incandescent light It's horses for courses stuff. For those contemplating a camera in the D300's price and purpose range It's a highly recommended choice. I agree with it too, incidentally. As for the Oly? The EP1 is in no way, shape or form a choice likely to be considered by someone shopping in the D300 market place. For someone who is looking for a highly portable camera that will pretty much fit in a shirt pocket whilst delivering good quality images... The EP1 is a highly recommended choice. In the 60's when I used Olympus cameras and their very excellent lenses, I used to look at the pens and wonder if they were likely to be useful to me. They weren't and I never owned one but there in lies the difference in cameras. I owned several OM1 cameras and a multitude of lenses for them. The Pen then - as it is now, was a travel camera and promoted as one - as it is now being promoted. How many people Rich, do you suppose would pack a D300, flash, grip and lenses for a weekend away at some beachside resort? I know... You would but that 's not the point. For a travel or happy snaps camera you probably couldn't go past an EP1. For wedding photography and the occasional wild life expedition into the wilds of Toronto... the D300 is absolutely a better "highly recommended choice". -- I'm coming back as a Pelican... Watch out because I'm staying the worlds biggest ass-hole! |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Dpreview's reviews "Highly Recommended" is highly questionable
Rich wrote:
On Jul 29, 8:01 pm, The pixel Bandit wrote: RichA wrote: Both cameras got "highly recommended." Evidently, it's a highly flexible attribution. E-P1 versus D300 Olympus E-P1: Conclusion - Pros (14) Excellent resolution, tons of detail in the shots Appealing, bright and punchy out of camera results and well optimized JPEGs Very clever collapsible kit lens that's small, but offers decent quality Unique retro design puts SLR quality into a compact body Good high ISO performance up to ISO 3200 and lots of control over noise reduction Superb build quality Decent handling Dual control dials - unusual design that works well Lots of external control, easy access to photographic functions Comprehensive feature set and impressive level of customization Reliable metering and white balance (in natural light) Lots of stuff to play with; art filters, aspect ratios, multi-exposure and level gauge In body image stabilization Easy to use, high quality video mode Conclusion - Cons (10) Slow focus requires a more considered approach to shooting Some highlight clipping (and poor dynamic range at ISO 100) Low resolution screen that's hard to see in bright light No viewfinder No built-in flash (and the optional flash is expensive and pretty basic) Complicated menu system not that easy to navigate Preview image brightness doesn't always match the captured image brightness Poor focus, slow lens and jerky live view image make shooting in very low light frustrating, to say the least No AF illuminator The most interesting Art Filters slow down operation (and make the movie mode virtually useless) Nikon D300: Conclusion - Pros (30) * Very good resolution and detail without looking over-processed, even up to ISO 1600 * Better balanced noise reduction than most; more chroma NR, less luminance NR * High ISO 3200 perfectly usable (if slightly softer due to NR), ISO 6400 usable for small output * Highly configurable Auto ISO function (can set maximum ISO and minimum shutter speed) * Conservative approach to image processing (slightly lower sharpening) helps to avoid 'digital' artifacts * Excellent dynamic range from ISO 200 - 800 (good highlight 'reach'), typical at ISO 1600 * Seldom mentioned built-in chromatic aberration reduction is very effective (JPEG, RAWs through NX) * Compact, solid body design with environmental sealing * Quality glass pentaprism viewfinder (bright, large view) with electronic grid lines * Professional in-use performance (instant power-up, short shutter lag and short viewfinder black-out) * Improved auto-focus module (Multi-CAM3500DX) delivers fast and accurate AF lock even in low light * Auto-focus fine-tuning by body or per lens * Nikon's excellent 1005 pixel RGB metering sensor * Numerous 'hidden' designed-in features; AF tracking by color, scene recognition system * High speed continuous shooting (6 fps) can be boosted to 8 fps with grip & battery * 150,000 exposure shutter life * Now Nikon standard range of image parameter presets, addition of brightness adjustment * Superb large, high resolution LCD (delivers full-color VGA; 640xRGB x 480) * Live view with up to 1:1 pixel view, contrast detect AF as well as passive (mirror flip) AF * HDMI video output (up to 1080i) * Compact Flash UDMA support, very fast throughput overall * Menu system is a pleasure to use, attractive, logical and built- in help * Easy to use playback with very logical delete system (press delete button twice) * Highly configurable via custom functions (6 configurable hard buttons / dials) * Sophisticated interval timer feature * Unique in-camera features: Overlay, Multiple exposures * GPS data recording feature (requires optional cable, NMEA compatible) * Built-in AF assist lamp (white light) * Probably the best battery information display in the business (% charge, shots, aging) * Optional wireless WiFi transmitter (802.11 b/g) Conclusion - Cons (3) * No timed mirror lock-up function (could be automatic with self- timer) * Non-articulating LCD (increases the usefulness of Live View considerably) * Average automatic white balance performance, still very poor under incandescent light It's horses for courses stuff. For those contemplating a camera in the D300's price and purpose range It's a highly recommended choice. I agree with it too, incidentally. As for the Oly? The EP1 is in no way, shape or form a choice likely to be considered by someone shopping in the D300 market place. For someone who is looking for a highly portable camera that will pretty much fit in a shirt pocket whilst delivering good quality images... The EP1 is a highly recommended choice. In the 60's when I used Olympus cameras and their very excellent lenses, I used to look at the pens and wonder if they were likely to be useful to me. They weren't and I never owned one but there in lies the difference in cameras. I owned several OM1 cameras and a multitude of lenses for them. The Pen then - as it is now, was a travel camera and promoted as one - as it is now being promoted. How many people Rich, do you suppose would pack a D300, flash, grip and lenses for a weekend away at some beachside resort? I know... You would but that 's not the point. For a travel or happy snaps camera you probably couldn't go past an EP1. Not indoor snaps, apparently. Evidently, Panasonic wouldn't share it's contrast detection technology with Olympus. The focus sucks, like a P&S only (according to Dpreview) worse than the best of those. That, coupled with a crappy low res LCD and no EVF that makes manual focusing a major chore is enough to have killed any self-respecting "highly recommended" recommendation. Yeah but it's a nice looking camera! -- I'm coming back as a Pelican... Watch out because I'm staying the worlds biggest ass-hole! |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
CHOKE! A Canon DSLR gets a "highly recommned - Just" on Dpreview! | Charles[_2_] | Digital SLR Cameras | 0 | November 7th 08 01:51 AM |
CHOKE! A Canon DSLR gets a "highly recommned - Just" onDpreview! | Wolfgang Weisselberg | Digital SLR Cameras | 0 | October 31st 08 01:52 PM |
Poor Pentax K10D. Just manages a "highly recommended" on dpreview | RichA | Digital SLR Cameras | 24 | December 21st 06 03:34 AM |
FujiFilm F30 "HIGHLY RECOMMENDED" | [email protected] | Digital Photography | 2 | November 22nd 06 12:01 PM |
Fujifilm FinePix F30 Rating: Excellent / Highly Recommended (9/10) | [email protected] | Digital Photography | 17 | August 7th 06 05:15 PM |